Ladies first
For its first decades, the race belonged to the mares. Chicquita won back-to-back editions in 1950 and 1951, twice finishing runner-up to Comic Court in that year’s Caulfield Cup and Melbourne Cup as part of one of the era’s defining rivalries; her old stable, Chicquita Lodge, still lends its name to a Flemington landmark. Bart Cummings’ Light Fingers won in 1965 before going on to give the trainer the first of his 12 Melbourne Cups – jockey Roy Higgins was famously so fond of her that he said he’d marry her if she could cook. Rose Of Kingston added her own chapter in 1982, backing up her Craiglee win with the Coongy Handicap and Australian Horse of the Year honours; her son Kingston Rule went on to win the 1990 Melbourne Cup.
A change of guard
Since the race took Makybe Diva’s name, the honour roll has told a different story. Southern Speed remains the only mare to win the renamed race, in 2012; every other name on the list since – Weekend Hussler, Northerly, Dissident, Incentivise, Shocking, I’m Thunderstruck – has been male.
Northerly’s win in 2002, while the race was still the Craiglee Stakes, stood out: the West Australian champion led throughout before adding the Caulfield Cup and Cox Plate that spring, reunited with jockey Greg Childs, who had ridden him to six straight wins including three at Group 1 level. Weekend Hussler took the 2008 edition as trainer Ross McDonald stretched his miler out towards the Caulfield Cup, Gatting produced one of the race’s great upsets at $101 in 2019, and Incentivise’s 2021 win launched a campaign that ran through the Turnbull Stakes and Caulfield Cup to a Melbourne Cup second.
Enter the war horse
Then, in 2023, along came a horse who would rewrite the race’s record book entirely. The Lindsay Park gelding Mr Brightside won that year, returned in 2024 to become the first horse since Sailor’s Guide in 1957 to win it twice, and went one better again in 2025 to become the race’s first three-time winner. Now nine, and coming back from his longest layoff yet, he lines up this year chasing a fourth – a feat that would put him in company with the likes of Winx and Manikato as one of Australian racing’s great serial winners. It is a story in its own right.